Every year, thousands of Pennsylvanians are
injured or killed in alcohol-related crashes. While drivers who choose to get
behind the wheel drunk are primarily responsible, they are not always the only
ones at fault. In certain circumstances, bars,
restaurants, and even private hosts may share liability if they served
alcohol to someone who was visibly intoxicated or underage.
This area of law is called dram shop liability. Victims of DUI crashes-and sometimes even
intoxicated individuals themselves-may be able to bring a dram shop lawsuit to
recover damages. Understanding these laws can be critical if you are trying to
hold all responsible parties accountable and maximize compensation.
For victims and families facing devastating losses, working with a seasoned Pennsylvania DUI accident attorney is often the only way to navigate these complex cases successfully.
Key Takeaways:
●
Pennsylvania’s dram shop law holds bars, restaurants, and social hosts accountable
for serving visibly intoxicated people or minors.
●
Victims of DUI crashes may pursue damages from
both the driver and the establishment.
●
Dram shop liability extends beyond car accidents
and can apply in assaults or self-inflicted injury cases.
●
Proving a dram shop claim requires evidence of
visible intoxication and a clear link between service and harm.
●
Victims may recover damages for medical bills,
lost wages, pain and suffering, and wrongful death.
●
Legal representation is critical because bars
and insurers often deny responsibility.
Dram
Shop Laws Explained: What They Are and Why They Exist
The term “dram
shop” comes from 18th-century England, when alcohol was sold by the dram (a
spoonful). Today, dram shop laws hold alcohol-serving establishments and social hosts legally responsible when
they serve alcohol to visibly intoxicated individuals or minors who later cause
injuries or death.
Why Do These Laws Exist?
The goal is twofold:
●
To give victims of drunk driving accidents
another path to recover damages.
●
To discourage reckless alcohol service and
prevent tragedies before they occur.
Pennsylvania’s dram shop law applies to:
●
Bars
and restaurants that serve visibly intoxicated customers.
●
Clubs
and event venues hosting patrons who over-consume.
●
Social
hosts who provide alcohol to minors.
By extending accountability
beyond the impaired driver, Pennsylvania law encourages safer alcohol service
across the board.
Beyond
Car Accidents: Other Cases Involving Dram Shop Liability
Although DUI crashes are the most common
scenario, dram shop claims can arise in
other types of personal injury cases. For example:
●
Assaults
and fights: If a visibly intoxicated person starts a fight
and injures someone, the bar that overserved them may be partly liable.
●
Self-inflicted
harm: In some cases, intoxicated individuals may
even sue establishments if they hurt themselves after being overserved.
This broad application makes
dram shop law a powerful tool for holding negligent establishments accountable.
Proving Dram Shop Liability:
What You Need to Show
Dram shop cases are not easy to win. They
require clear evidence that an establishment violated its duty of care. To
succeed, a plaintiff typically must prove three key elements:
1. The Customer Was Visibly Intoxicated
Visible intoxication means more than simply
having alcohol in their system. Signs include:
●
Staggering or difficulty walking
●
Slurred speech
●
Aggressive or crude behavior
●
Bloodshot eyes
●
Ordering multiple drinks rapidly
Witnesses, receipts, and surveillance footage
may help demonstrate these signs.
2. The Establishment Served Alcohol Despite Obvious Impairment
The second step is showing that the bar,
restaurant, or host continued to serve
alcohol after impairment was clear. Testimony from servers, other
customers, or video evidence may be used.
3. The Intoxication Directly Led to Harm
Finally, the intoxicated person’s actions must
be directly linked to the injuries suffered. In DUI cases, a guilty plea, high
BAC test, or conviction is strong evidence.
Learn more about DUI defense and
evidence in Pennsylvania.
Recoverable Damages in a
Pennsylvania Dram Shop Case
If you succeed in bringing a dram shop claim,
you may be able to recover significant compensation for both economic and
non-economic losses. These may include:
●
Medical
bills (past and future)
●
Lost
income and reduced earning capacity
●
Pain
and suffering
●
Loss
of companionship or consortium
●
Loss
of enjoyment of life
●
Funeral
expenses in wrongful death cases
Because multiple parties may share
responsibility (the drunk driver, the establishment, and possibly others), dram
shop cases often increase the likelihood of a meaningful recovery for victims.
For families who have lost a loved one in a
crash, our attorneys also handle wrongful
death cases with compassion and determination.
How
Dram Shop Liability Strengthens Victims’ Cases
Pursuing dram shop liability serves more than
financial recovery-it serves public safety. When establishments face the
possibility of being held liable, they are less likely to over-serve patrons in
the future.
Holding a negligent bar accountable can:
●
Provide justice for victims and families.
●
Prevent future tragedies.
●
Send a message that profits should never come before safety.
At Perna & Abracht, we believe that victims deserve to hold every responsible party accountable, not just the impaired driver.
Common Defenses Raised by
Bars and Restaurants
Bars and restaurants rarely accept
responsibility without a fight. Common defenses include:
●
The
customer did not appear intoxicated.
●
No
causal link between the alcohol service and the accident.
●
Intervening
factors, such as the victim’s own conduct.
●
Insufficient
evidence of visible intoxication.
This is why building a strong case with the help
of a skilled
criminal lawyer is essential. Our firm conducts thorough
investigations, gathering surveillance video, interviewing witnesses, and using
toxicology experts when needed.
Explore how we defend clients in DUI-related
cases.
It is important to note that serving alcohol to
a minor is always illegal,
regardless of whether they appear intoxicated. Bars, restaurants, and social
hosts can face both criminal and civil penalties for providing alcohol to
under-21 individuals.
This is particularly relevant in college towns
like West Chester, where underage drinking is common. Dram shop laws provide
additional protection for young victims of DUI crashes.
Learn more about underage DUI laws in Pennsylvania.
How Dram Shop Claims Fit
Within Broader DUI Litigation
Dram shop lawsuits often run alongside criminal
DUI prosecutions and civil car accident claims. For victims, this means
multiple paths to recovery:
●
Criminal
DUI case: Focuses on punishing the driver.
●
Civil
car accident claim: Seeks damages from the driver’s insurance.
●
Dram
shop claim: Adds accountability for bars, restaurants, or
hosts.
Working with attorneys who handle both DUI defense and personal injury matters ensures no avenue of recovery is overlooked.
Why Legal Representation is
Essential in Dram Shop Cases
Dram shop cases are legally and factually
complex. They require deep knowledge of both DUI law and personal injury law.
At Perna & Abracht, our attorneys bring decades of combined experience
handling high-stakes cases in Chester County
and across Pennsylvania.
We know how to:
●
Investigate alcohol service practices
●
Secure witness testimony and surveillance video
●
Work with toxicology experts
●
Navigate court procedures and negotiations
See our guide on the consequences of DUI in Pennsylvania.
Conclusion: Holding All
Responsible Parties Accountable
DUI accidents leave victims with devastating
injuries, emotional trauma, and financial burdens. While impaired drivers must
face consequences, so too should the businesses or hosts that enabled them.
Dram shop
liability empowers victims to demand accountability from all responsible
parties. By holding negligent bars and restaurants
accountable, victims not only recover the compensation they deserve but also
help protect the community from future harm.
If you were injured or lost a loved one in a DUI crash and believe that a bar, restaurant, or social host may share responsibility, do not wait. Contact Perna & Abracht, LLC today to schedule a complimentary consultation with an experienced DUI accident lawyer
